Tips for Designing a Board Game

In this post, I am going to give you a series of tips—or habits that work for me—for designing a board game with a minimum investment of time and resources.

 

Tip No. 1: Define from the outset what kind of game you want to design

 

For example, I am going to design a card game with a minimum of 50 cards and a maximum of 80, aimed at people who are familiar with board games but currently want to play a filler game—a game intended to fill short periods of time. It will make use of trick-taking mechanics, with fast-paced, improvised gameplay and hostile interactions between players.

 

This is not the same as first deciding that it will be a card game without defining the number of components, then exploring different possibilities and creating various prototypes that may or may not work. You might then modify the game to see whether it better suits the target audience, which could give you contradictory ideas depending on who offers their opinion. You might come up with ideas for 200 cards, only to realize that so many cards are difficult to store and then have to choose between them. After that, you might test the game again to see whether the changes work and try to reduce the number of components to make it commercially viable, and so on.

 

The first option is much better because you already have a clear idea of what you want to achieve, you know what resources you have, and you have a fairly clear understanding of what you need to do and test to reach the desired result. You might think that this limits creativity, but it does not have to. Creativity is not based on the number of ideas—good or bad—that you are able to come up with. If you enjoy that process, go ahead, but if you want to design a tangible game, it is not the fastest or most direct approach. Creativity is based on the quality of the ideas you implement.

 

Let us go back to the first example. Instead of thinking about which ideas to apply to our game, we focus on which game-design tools we can use and combine to optimize the result we want to achieve: a trick-taking game in which players act quickly, improvise, and compete intensely against one another.

 

First of all, since we have defined the scope of our game, we have a better idea of what we can use to optimize it. We can even adopt mechanics from very different games and adapt them appropriately to what we want to convey during play, without getting lost in the details.

 

Imagine a trick-taking game with hidden roles in which we have to try to prevent our characters from being eliminated. It is a trick-taking game, but that does not restrict or limit our creative process. Since we already know that we have a maximum of 80 cards, we also know how many players the game should accommodate, how many cards each player should have, and how long the game should last. This enables us to design the gameplay much more effectively than if we started with an isolated idea—“a trick-taking game, and we will see what happens”—and then developed it through a series of random missteps from one design to another.

 

Secondly, this approach allows us to save on the components we use. If the game has a maximum of 80 cards, we are not going to create prototypes with 200 cards. This has an additional benefit: we will be much more creative with 80 cards than with 200. If we have a mechanic that requires 120 cards, sooner or later we will find a way to adapt it to 80 cards, because that is the limit we have set ourselves. This is one way to train our creativity.

 

Thirdly, our brain will already have such a clear idea of what we want to do with the game that it will continue generating new ideas that can be added to what we already have. If players are supposed to compete intensely while playing, how can I create incentives that encourage them to keep doing so? How can I prevent analysis paralysis when players are choosing a card? What should I do to implement these mechanics in a filler game without requiring players to perform additional calculations, while still producing varied results and providing some strategic depth?

 

For these reasons, if you start with a clear and solid idea of what you want to create, you will not only design the game more quickly, but it will also be much more fun than if you design it haphazardly.

 

Tip No. 2: Buy a notebook and a pen or pencil

 

It may sound silly, but your best ideas will not necessarily occur while you are designing the game. If designing is almost an obsession for you—that is, if you carry the game around in your head for much of the day—you will come up with brilliant ideas while walking, watching television, watching videos online, working out at the gym, taking a walk in the countryside, attending a social gathering, and so on.

 

If you try to keep the idea in your head until you return to your editing document, it is very likely that you will have already forgotten it.

 

But that is not the only advantage of having a notebook: writing down the ideas that occur to you at the moment. The main advantage is that you will see your idea written down on paper. Then, if you have a minimally creative mind—and you almost certainly do if you design board games—you will come up with more ideas. If you write those ideas down on the paper as well, even more ideas will emerge, and this will continue until you have had enough.

 

It is like a nuclear reactor. Sooner or later, you will not need the notebook merely to record the ideas that occur to you spontaneously; you will need it to relieve your mind of the countless ideas that keep appearing as you go along. Combined with the first tip, this can lead you to generate so many prototypes that you will have to create lists of games to develop just so you can finish at least some of them.

 

Tip No. 3: Focus on the experience of the users you want to reach, and design the game for that type of user

 

If you are making a game for beginners, your design concepts may be highly sophisticated—whether thematically, statistically, mathematically, or in other ways—in order to give the game considerable depth. Even so, try to make the rules easy to explain and understand. Mastering the game can still require more experience, which will be what attracts more demanding players.

 

In other words, try to adapt your game to the abilities and preferences of the audience it is intended for. If you are targeting experienced players, a game with simple rules and no depth may feel too limited for them. It is possible that such a game would be suitable for children, in which case you will need to change your target audience, because it will not serve the experienced-player market.

 

If your target audience does not like competition at all, do not include competition in your game.

 

Then, generate ideas that would be interesting to that audience. You could research history if your game is about civilizations, or study the rules of sports if you are creating a car-racing game. Try to translate those ideas into game mechanics, and then harmonize those mechanics with your game design. In this way, you will have a toolkit—remember the second tip—that will allow you to complete your games in the most varied and effective ways possible.

 

Since this article is getting quite long, I will leave the remaining tips for another time.